Site Navigation


Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C.

"Welcome to Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C."

About Us

Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C. is an independent agency located in Watertown, WI. Our insurance companies offer coverage throughout Wisconsin at competitive rates. We offer auto (including SR-22), home, renters, farm, worker's compensation and business insurances. We also offer security, fidelity, notary bonds with a public notary on staff, please call for an appt. We have many companies to choose from including 1st Auto & Casualty, Lebanon Clyman Mutual, Dairyland, Progressive, Forward Mutual, Grinnell Mutual, Hartford Insurance (Flood), JM Wilson, Sugar Creek Mutual, Riverside Mutual Insurance and Central Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company. Contact us for a quote today (920)-261-3334 & visit us on Facebook! Thanks, Shelley

Areas Served


Our Professional Associations

Our Certifications

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Our Services include:

Our Brands include:


On 5/16/2023 Gary Mills had this to say:
I was with another company. Just raised my rates. Patronizing me over the cost of a sheet of plywood. really. I moved from Illinois, to Watertown WI. A little frustrated, I decided to go LOCAL. I investigated insurance companies in Watertown. Saxby Ins online had the most to offer so I selected Saxby's. I had my initial appointment, I felt very at home and safe, I wasn't going to be taken. Immediately Shelley reviewed my current polices, auto and home, found some interesting things, Shelley did her magic, and saved me near 900 dollars PLUS giving me BETTER coverage. I'm glad to be a Saxby Insurance member. Thank you. Testimonial written by Gary Mills on this site.

On 12/22/2022 Milt Laforge had this to say:
Shelly is very friendly and very very helpful. saved me 160.00 a month

On 10/19/2022 Kayla L. had this to say:
I hate that I forgot her name but the blonde lady was so extra helpful and courteous and patient with me. Her dog is maverick tho lol and he's a good boy

On 7/26/2022 Dariela Martinez had this to say:
She was so kind and explained everything thoroughly and in a way we understood:) Great attitude and really saved me more money than any of the other places i had previously gone to. 10/10 recommend Testimonial written by Dariela Martinez on this site.

On 5/31/2022 Ethan Maurice had this to say:
The agent, Shelley, was competent and fast with her work. I signed up for a place on a Friday, Monday was a holiday and Shelley was able to have policy confirmation to me that I could send to my landlord by Tuesday. Their customer service is second to none, and they explained their policy structure well. They even helped me avoid an extra monthly charge by paying annually. I’d recommend Saxby to anyone looking for renters insurance!

Contact Us

Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C.
210 W Main St Watertown, WI 53094
Phone: (920) 261-3334
Fax: (920) 261-3530

Across the street from the Library. Next to Mullen's Dairy

Where To Find Us

Follow us on Google
Follow us on Facebook
Follow us on Yelp

Payment Types Accepted

Visa, MasterCard, Personal Checks, Debit Cards, Cash

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 9:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 12:00 PM




Terms of Use
Privacy Policy